What A Man's Got to Murder Monday
Aug. 7th, 2017 06:43 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
evelyn_bWhat I've Finished Reading
I finished Murder in Three Acts in about two days - it just walked in and took over all my reading time without any effort. Mr. Satterthwaite, the quietly observant "womanish" bachelor from The Mysterious Mr. Quinn, returns for a crossover with Hercule Poirot. There's been one mysterious death at a cocktail party when Mr. Satterthwaite and his friends (an actor with alarmingly mutable mannerisms and a winning young woman with the unwinning nickname of Egg) begin their investigation, and no sooner have they begun poking around than another chap from the same party fetches up dead, apparently by the same method.
I thought I'd figured out the real killer at about the halfway point - and I turned out to be right - but I didn't know why until the very end. The solution was, in fact, right there all along, a beautiful piece of fair-play misdirection.
But Murder in Three Acts has something else, something rare and precious: Hercule Poirot backstory!
This doesn't completely confirm my headcanon that Poirot grew up in a chaotic household with lots of brothers and sisters (all with heroic names) but it's close enough for me.
What I'm Reading Now
I love The Brass Rainbow, even if it's confusing in the way these hard-boileds are almost always confusing to me - I don't know why I find it so hard to keep track of who's blackmailing which coffee-mogul's son in re: what mob-adjacent gambling debts, but I do. I couldn't pass a pop quiz on The Brass Rainbow, but maybe that's not the point. Life is like that sometimes. It's even more like that than usual if you're One-Armed Detective Dan Fortune, who is always saying things like
Do any of these guys ever succeed in making life less of a nightmare? Or is that also not quite the point? No one goes to the underworld expecting to reform it. Your best-case scenario is getting what you came for and getting out, and how often do you see a best-case scenario? You don't.
What I Plan to Read Next
Unfinished Portrait by Mary Westmacott! (not a murder story). Maybe this Women Sleuths anthology.
I finished Murder in Three Acts in about two days - it just walked in and took over all my reading time without any effort. Mr. Satterthwaite, the quietly observant "womanish" bachelor from The Mysterious Mr. Quinn, returns for a crossover with Hercule Poirot. There's been one mysterious death at a cocktail party when Mr. Satterthwaite and his friends (an actor with alarmingly mutable mannerisms and a winning young woman with the unwinning nickname of Egg) begin their investigation, and no sooner have they begun poking around than another chap from the same party fetches up dead, apparently by the same method.
I thought I'd figured out the real killer at about the halfway point - and I turned out to be right - but I didn't know why until the very end. The solution was, in fact, right there all along, a beautiful piece of fair-play misdirection.
But Murder in Three Acts has something else, something rare and precious: Hercule Poirot backstory!
"See you, as a boy I was poor. There were many of us. We had to get on in the world. I entered the police force. I worked hard. Slowly I rose in that force. I began to make a name for myself.
This doesn't completely confirm my headcanon that Poirot grew up in a chaotic household with lots of brothers and sisters (all with heroic names) but it's close enough for me.
What I'm Reading Now
I love The Brass Rainbow, even if it's confusing in the way these hard-boileds are almost always confusing to me - I don't know why I find it so hard to keep track of who's blackmailing which coffee-mogul's son in re: what mob-adjacent gambling debts, but I do. I couldn't pass a pop quiz on The Brass Rainbow, but maybe that's not the point. Life is like that sometimes. It's even more like that than usual if you're One-Armed Detective Dan Fortune, who is always saying things like
Life begins in darkness and ends in darkness and in between is a nightmare.
A man in a bar in Algiers told me that. It was in my mind when I woke up to the gray cold of another day.
All you can do, that man said, is stay out of it. He may be right, but life is short. If you stay out you'll never know if you could have done something to make it less of a nightmare. Like doing something about men who push other men under trains.
Do any of these guys ever succeed in making life less of a nightmare? Or is that also not quite the point? No one goes to the underworld expecting to reform it. Your best-case scenario is getting what you came for and getting out, and how often do you see a best-case scenario? You don't.
What I Plan to Read Next
Unfinished Portrait by Mary Westmacott! (not a murder story). Maybe this Women Sleuths anthology.
no subject
Date: 2017-08-07 12:42 pm (UTC)Also I would never have guessed that Poirot grew up poor or with a passel of heroically named brothers & sisters, but now that you've mentioned the possibility... I could definitely see his current insistence on order as a reaction against a chaotic youth.
Although probably at least one or those brothers and sisters would have become a criminal mastermind and/or a common murder who Poirot had to hunt down, so that is a strike against the large family theory.
no subject
Date: 2017-08-07 01:27 pm (UTC)Little Hercule tried to have a private milk crate for his one good jacket and the silver-plated hair-care kit he saved up to buy at the pawn shop but Orphée put spiders in it, not maliciously, just because he liked spiders and thought everyone else should too, and Atalante managed to kick it out of position every morning on her way to knocking over the water pitcher, and Athene stood on it when she was trying to get the little roof window open. Her foot went straight through the old wood and left a nasty mark on the jacket Hercule had folded so carefully, and she never got the window open, either. There is a lot to be said for living alone.
no subject
Date: 2017-08-07 06:16 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2017-08-08 09:38 am (UTC)LOL. Although, consider, that could have happened when he was working for the Belgian police, so it's all still plausible!
(I clearly could do with re-reading Three Act Tragedy, as I remember nothing about it at all and seem to have it vaguely muddled up with Lord Edgeware Dies for some reason. Possibly because there are actors in both. Who knows?)